I'm not at all surprised to find out that Unshelved is not funny. But I guess you could help change that.

There's the essence of a good idea in here, but the problem is that all the dedicated readers of a given comic strip, i.e. the ones who find it funniest, will never go to this site. They'll just keep reading their favorites as normal. But I'm still entertained by the whole thing.

Of course everything we write in Unshelved is quotable, but the punchline of this Book Club strip was the Quote Of The Day here and at Google.